CH4-PIN-157
Pinheiro Principle 15.7: states may, in situations of mass displacement where little documentary evidence exists as to ownership or rights of possession, adopt the conclusive presumption that persons fleeing during a period marked by violence or disaster did so for related reasons and are entitled to restitution; administrative and judicial authorities may independently establish the facts of undocumented claims
مضمون هذا الصفّ بلغته الأصلية؛ وأسماء الحقول وشروحها بالعربية.
- المعرّف
- الادّعاء
- Pinheiro Principle 15.7: states may, in situations of mass displacement where little documentary evidence exists as to ownership or rights of possession, adopt the conclusive presumption that persons fleeing during a period marked by violence or disaster did so for related reasons and are entitled to restitution; administrative and judicial authorities may independently establish the facts of undocumented claims
- أين يستخدمه الكتاب
- Chapter 4 (سجلّ عمل داخلي, the Pinheiro section at lines 61 to 69)
- الحالة
- SUPPORTED(فُتحت وثيقة أصلية وهي تقول هذا)
- المصدر
- نوع المصدر
- Primary United Nations instrument, E/CN.4/Sub.2/2005/17, endorsed by Sub-Commission resolution 2005/21
- تاريخ النشر
- 2005-06-28
- تاريخ قراءة المؤلف له
- 2026-09-16
- ما الذي يقيسه، وحدوده
- Opened 16 September 2026 at محفوظة في أرشيف المؤلف, Principle 15.7 at page 12; the chapter's quotation at line 63 matches the instrument word for word ('ownership or rights of possession'). The handbook SRC-098 reprints the clause as 'ownership or possessory rights' in its closing pages; the chapter states the divergence at line 65
- أدلة متعارضة
- None on the instrument's text. Whether Syria's Law 33 of 2017 reconstitution route or Law 10's claim window satisfies the Principle is not asserted anywhere in the book (issue 47)
- سؤال للاختصاصيين
- Issue 47, SPECIALIST_REVIEW, OPEN: the Principles' application to Syrian claims is a question, not settled advice
- مواضع أخرى تعتمد عليه
- Chapter 4 lines 63 and 65; line 207 (the occupant paragraph points back to the Pinheiro section). Opened on MIN-319 (M5 of the v8 diff review), which found no claim row covered 15.7 or 17.1
- قاعدة استخدامه
- Quote the Principle or paraphrase it with its own modal (may, should, shall); do not present it as binding law or as settled advice while issue 47 is open
- نسخة الصفّ
- 0.1