CH1-004
WITHDRAWN AND REVERSED. I claimed that correcting for price basis moves the United Nations and World Bank capital figures further apart. It moves them closer, and the World Bank had already done the correction in its own annex
مضمون هذا الصفّ بلغته الأصلية؛ وأسماء الحقول وشروحها بالعربية.
- المعرّف
- الادّعاء
- WITHDRAWN AND REVERSED. I claimed that correcting for price basis moves the United Nations and World Bank capital figures further apart. It moves them closer, and the World Bank had already done the correction in its own annex
- أين يستخدمه الكتاب
- Chapter 1
- الحالة
- SUPERSEDED(استبدلته الجهة نفسها، والصفّ محفوظ جزءاً من السجل)
- المصدر
- World Bank assessment, Annex 2, Review of Previous Assessments, Table 10, printed page 49
- نوع المصدر
- Official assessment, primary document opened by page rendering
- تاريخ النشر
- 2026-08-10
- تاريخ قراءة المؤلف له
- 2026-08-10
- ما الذي يقيسه، وحدوده
- Table 10 restates every previous study to December 2024 values, by footnote 5 using CPI and exchange-rate adjustments. UNDP 2025 physical damage goes from 123 in 2010 constant prices to 117 adjusted. UNESCWA 2020 goes from 118 to 112. The World Bank's own figure is 108. So adjusted, the three sit within about 8 per cent, closer than the unadjusted comparison and not further away
- أدلة متعارضة
- My error was assuming a United States CPI uplift from 2010 to 2024 would raise the figure. The Bank's adjustment combines CPI with exchange-rate effects, and against a collapsed Syrian pound the net movement is downward. I reasoned about the direction of an adjustment instead of opening the annex that had performed it
- سؤال للاختصاصيين
- Economist review desirable on the deflator choice before any restated figure is printed
- مواضع أخرى تعتمد عليه
- Chapter 1 convergence section; supersedes source line 159
- قاعدة استخدامه
- Do not print the reversed claim. Chapter 1 v2 states the Bank's own adjusted figures and attributes the adjustment to the Bank
- نسخة الصفّ
- 0.2