CH1-007
The US$250 billion figure has two candidate origins and the manuscript asserts only one of them
مضمون هذا الصفّ بلغته الأصلية؛ وأسماء الحقول وشروحها بالعربية.
- المعرّف
- الادّعاء
- The US$250 billion figure has two candidate origins and the manuscript asserts only one of them
- أين يستخدمه الكتاب
- Chapter 1
- الحالة
- SUPERSEDED(استبدلته الجهة نفسها، والصفّ محفوظ جزءاً من السجل)
- المصدر
- World Bank assessment Annex 2 printed page 49, against source manuscript line 157
- نوع المصدر
- Official assessment against the manuscript
- تاريخ النشر
- 2025-10-21
- تاريخ قراءة المؤلف له
- 2026-08-10
- ما الذي يقيسه، وحدوده
- The manuscript states the US$250 billion at the low end of the ILO range is the same quantity measured by the Syrian Centre for Policy Research in 2015. The Bank's annex instead records that in November 2017 the UN Special Envoy Staffan de Mistura reported to the Security Council that rebuilding Syria would require at least US$250 billion, citing Humud and Blanchard 2019, and separately lists SCPR 2015 total economic losses at 255 in 2010 prices
- أدلة متعارضة
- Two plausible origins for the same round number, one a reconstruction requirement stated by an envoy and one a total economic loss measured by a research centre. They are different quantities that happen to sit at the same figure SUPERSEDED IN PART, 12 August 2026, and the conflict is named rather than resolved silently. This row asserts that the EPRS briefing cites no source for either end of its range, and its Action cell said not to attribute the low end to any source. THAT IS NO LONGER WHAT THE DOCUMENT SHOWS. The briefing carries five link annotations on the range sentence; the one on the word 'cost' points to the Atlantic Council commentary at SRC-065, which states $250 billion to $400 billion. Chapter 1 v10 now attributes the floor to that commentary. The row's negative limb is withdrawn; what survives is that the briefing prints no footnote and no in-text citation, which is a different and narrower claim. NEW ACTION: the low end is attributed to SRC-065 and to nothing else, and the briefing is described as linking rather than citing.
- سؤال للاختصاصيين
- None
- مواضع أخرى تعتمد عليه
- Chapter 1 citation chase
- قاعدة استخدامه
- Resolved 10 August 2026 by opening the chain. The EPRS briefing gives no source for either end of its range, so neither the SCPR attribution nor the de Mistura attribution can be carried as the ILO figure's origin. Chapter 1 states that the low end arrives without a source and does not adopt one
- نسخة الصفّ
- 0.1